Air Pillows vs Bubble Wrap for Shipping: Cost, Pros & Cons

The Ultimate Showdown: Air Pillows vs Bubble Wrap

Before we examine each option individually, understanding the fundamental differences among these popular void-filling solutions will help frame your decision-making process. 

Both air pillows and bubble wrap serve the same primary purpose: protecting products during transit, but they do so in distinctly different ways.

Protection Level Differences

Bubble wrap's primary strength lies in its direct contact protection capabilities. The air-filled bubbles create a cushioning barrier that absorbs impact and vibration directly against the product surface. 

This makes it particularly effective for wrapping irregularly shaped items or those with delicate surfaces. Air pillows, by contrast, excel at void filling-they prevent items from shifting inside boxes during transit by filling empty spaces, creating a suspension effect rather than direct cushioning.

Cost Impact on Shipping Operations

The cost equation extends far beyond the per-unit price of packaging materials. Bubble wrap typically costs from around £4.95 for small rolls, and large 100m rolls range from approximately £11 to over £29, while pre-inflated air pillows start from around £11.50 to £30+ for smaller packs. 

However, the real cost difference emerges when considering dimensional weight pricing used by major carriers. Because air pillows weigh significantly less than bubble wrap, they can substantially reduce shipping costs for businesses sending high volumes of packages.

Air Pillows: The Modern Void Fill Solution

How Air Pillows Work

Air pillows can come pre-filled or flat, depending on your choice. Deflated air pillows usually require a machine that inflates the plastic film into cushions on demand. The equipment ranges from small tabletop units suitable for low-volume operations to automated systems capable of producing thousands of pillows per hour. 

Most equipment allows operators to adjust fill pressure and pillow size depending on protection requirements. The film comes in rolls that remain flat until needed, then transform into protective cushions through a simple inflation process.

Modern air pillow machines connect directly to packing stations, allowing workers to create void fill exactly when needed. This just-in-time production model eliminates the need to pre-make packaging materials, reducing waste and increasing efficiency.

Space-Saving Benefits for Warehouse Operations

The space efficiency of air pillow systems cannot be overstated when evaluating warehouse operations. For example, a 15 cubic foot bag can contain 750 air pillows measuring 100mm x 200mm. This minimal storage requirement allows businesses to dedicate more space to inventory or reduce their warehouse footprint entirely. 

For businesses operating in areas with high real estate costs, the storage savings alone can justify the switch to air pillows.  Additionally, the compact storage format reduces the frequency of supply deliveries, cutting receiving costs and minimising the transportation sector's environmental impact.

Cons of Air Pillows

Despite their advantages, air pillows aren't without limitations. The most significant drawback is their inability to provide direct surface protection. Unlike bubble wrap, which conforms to product contours, air pillows primarily protect by preventing movement within the package.

This makes them less suitable for items with delicate surfaces that require cushioning against scratches or abrasion. Equipment dependency presents another potential disadvantage, especially for flat films, when an air pillow machine malfunctions, packing operations may grind to a halt if backup systems aren't available. 

Additionally, air pillows require electricity to produce, making them vulnerable to power outages. Some businesses mitigate this risk by purchasing pre-inflated pillows or alternative void fill options.

Bubble Wrap: The Classic Protection Standard

Superior Cushioning for Fragile Items

Bubble wrap's direct contact with product surfaces creates a cushioning effect that's particularly valuable for fragile items. The air-filled bubbles absorb vibration and impact forces, dispersing energy that would otherwise transfer to the product. 

This protection mechanism is especially effective for glass, ceramics, and delicate electronics, where even minor impacts could cause significant damage. The customisable protection level represents another considerable advantage of bubble wrap. Small-bubble varieties (3/16") provide excellent surface protection against scratches and minor impacts, while larger-bubble varieties (1/2") offer superior cushioning against major shocks. 

By selecting the appropriate bubble size and wrapping technique, businesses can create tailored protection for virtually any product, from antique glassware to industrial equipment.

When Bubble Wrap Is The Better Choice

Specific shipping scenarios strongly favour bubble wrap, regardless of cost. Antiques, artwork, scientific instruments, and luxury items with high-value densities benefit from bubble wrap's superior surface-level protection. 

These items often require both cushioning and immobilisation that air pillows alone cannot provide. Products with polished or painted surfaces present another scenario where bubble wrap excels. Direct-contact protection prevents scratching and surface marring, maintaining the aesthetic quality that may be as important as structural integrity. 

For businesses shipping high-end retail products where presentation matters, bubble wrap's ability to prevent cosmetic damage offers significant value.

Cons of Bubble Wrap

Despite its protective benefits, bubble wrap has significant drawbacks. Its pre-inflated format consumes substantial warehouse space, with a standard pallet of bubble wrap occupying approximately 30–40 cubic feet. 

This storage inefficiency creates logistical challenges for businesses with limited facilities and increases inventory carrying costs. Labour intensity represents another significant disadvantage. Properly wrapping items with bubble wrap requires significantly more time than filling voids with air pillows. 

Environmental concerns also impact bubble wrap's viability in today's sustainability-conscious market. Though technically recyclable, most residential recycling programs reject bubble wrap, leaving approximately 95% to end up in landfills. 

Side-by-Side Comparison: Air Pillows vs Bubble Wrap 

Why Globe Packaging Is Your Best Choice for Air Pillows and Bubble Wrap

C: Globe Packaging is a UK-based packaging supplier that specialises in protective packaging items like bubble wraps, foam wrap rolls, corrugated paper rolls, and many more. 

AT: Globe Packaging logo. 

At Globe Packaging, we stock a comprehensive range of air pillows and bubble wraps. As one of the UK's leading online packaging distributors, we offer competitive pricing on bubble wrap in various sizes and thicknesses, alongside modern void fill alternatives-all available with next working day delivery on orders placed by 4 PM.

Our commitment goes beyond just supplying products. We pride ourselves on market-leading service levels and helping businesses optimise their packaging strategy for maximum protection at minimum cost. Whether you're shipping delicate glassware requiring premium bubble wrap or need efficient void fill for e-commerce orders, Globe Packaging has the quality materials and expert guidance to support your operations. 

Trust us for exceptional value, reliable delivery, and packaging solutions that protect your products and your bottom line.

Shop Globe Packaging Now →

*Note: Product listings, prices, and delivery times shown are approximate and subject to change. Contact Globe Packaging for the latest information.